Do companies post fake jobs?
We can’t answer that, and we won’t pretend to. “Fake” is a claim about what an employer intended, and intent is not visible on a careers page. There is no measurement — ours or anyone else’s — that separates a posting nobody means to fill from a role that has simply proved hard to hire for.
What is measurable: 19.1% of the 524,322 postings we track have been listed 90 days or longer, and 4.4% for a year or longer. That is a fact about duration. It is not a fake-job rate, and the difference between those two sentences is the entire subject of this page.
Why intent isn't measurable from outside
Everything we collect comes from employers’ own public careers pages: what is listed, the date the employer gives for it, and the day it stops appearing. That is enough to say how long something was advertised. It is not enough to say why.
Consider two postings, both listed for eight months. In one, the role was cancelled in month two and nobody took the listing down. In the other, the employer has interviewed eleven people and not found the right one. From a careers page these are byte-for-byte indistinguishable. Any site that tells you which is which has decided rather than measured.
The reasons commonly offered for keeping listings up — building a candidate pool, projecting growth, satisfying an internal policy that roles be advertised — are things people report, not things we observe. We pass them on as claims and don’t attach numbers to them.
What the duration data does support
Two things are worth saying plainly. First, the majority of what we track is recent and unremarkable — the median posting has been up 32 days. Second, there is a persistent tail that does not clear: 99,913 listings at three months or more, and the oldest currently at 5,010 days.
The removal data adds a wrinkle rather than a verdict. Of 267,708 postings we watched come down, 19,136 later reappeared under the same listing. That is a real pattern with several possible causes, and we can distinguish the pattern without being able to distinguish the causes.
What you can do instead of guessing
Check the age. It is the one input available to you before you spend an evening on an application, and unlike a fakeness verdict it is a fact. Paste any posting below and we’ll tell you how long it has been listed and whether it is still up.
You can also look at the longest-open postings we track, read what people mean by a ghost job, or see how we date and count postings.
Check how long a posting has been listed
Sign in and paste a job link to find a current public listing and its employer posting date, when available.
What this doesn’t tell you
Nothing here is an estimate of how many postings are fake. We publish how long listings have been up. Reading a duration figure as a fakeness figure substitutes a definition for a measurement, and we would be doing that on behalf of employers we name elsewhere on this site.
Long-lived postings have ordinary explanations. Specialist roles with small candidate pools, approvals that sit with someone for months, hiring freezes that arrive after a listing goes up, and listings nobody remembers to remove all look the same from outside.
We name no employer on this page. Not as an example, not as a counter-example. Our company pages publish posting counts and ages and let readers draw their own conclusions; that is a different thing from associating a company with this question.
Related questions
- How long do job postings stay up?The full distribution of posting age across every board we crawl, with the industry breakdown.
- How long does it take to hear back after applying?Nobody can measure an employer's reply from outside. What can be measured is how long the posting lasts.
- Why am I not hearing back from jobs?How much of what is listed right now has been listed for a very long time, and what that does and does not explain.
- What does it mean when a job posting is taken down after an interview?How old postings are when they come down, how often they come back, and why removal is not a decision.
- How many applications does it take to get a job?We cannot answer this one, and we say why. What we can show you is the size and staleness of what is open.
- What is a ghost job?The term describes an intention. We can only measure duration — so here is the duration, and where the line sits.
- How long does the hiring process take?Posting lifespan is a floor on hiring time, not a measure of it. The difference matters and is explained.
Or look up a specific employer: browse the companies we track, see the longest-open postings, or read how these numbers are produced.